Direct answer
A good website design is measurable. Here are 12 checks with a pass mark each: phone speed, one main action, contact in one tap, tap size, contrast, readable type, proof next to the call to action, only the pages you need, short labelled forms, titles and one H1, accounts in your name, and a named person who updates it.
This page is for small and growing businesses and medium companies. It is a website design checklist you can run yourself, not a ranking forecast and not a Lighthouse score.
How to use it
Set aside 15 minutes and a phone. Score each check pass or fail — no half marks. Use the website grader for the speed and mobile checks; do the rest by looking at the live pages.
Count the passes out of 12. The table below is this page's reading of that count, not a Google band.
The 12 checks
Each check has a pass mark. Where a primary source exists — web.dev Core Web Vitals, WCAG 2.2 SC 2.5.8, SC 1.4.3, SC 1.4.4, SC 3.3.2, or Google's title-link documentation — the pass mark cites it. The rest are this page's pass marks, labelled as such.
1. Speed on a phone
- What to test
- How fast the largest content paints, how soon the page responds to a tap, and whether the layout jumps while it loads — measured on a phone.
- Pass mark
- LCP at or under 2.5 seconds, INP at or under 200 milliseconds, and CLS at or under 0.1, at the 75th percentile.
- How to test
- Run the website grader on a public URL. Field LCP, INP, and CLS appear when Google has Chrome UX Report data; they are the pass marks. If field data is missing, the lab Lighthouse run on a phone is a stand-in, not a substitute.
Source: Web Vitals | web.dev, read 20 November 2026.
2. One main action per page
- What to test
- What the page asks a visitor to do first.
- Pass mark
- Each page has one primary call to action. Other links are visually quieter. This is this page's pass mark, not a WCAG criterion.
- How to test
- Open home, one service page, and contact. Count competing buttons above the fold on a phone.
Pass mark on this page, not a published standard.
3. Contact or booking in one tap
- What to test
- Whether a visitor on a phone can call, email, or book without hunting.
- Pass mark
- A tel: link, mailto: link, or booking control is reachable in one tap from the first screen, or from a persistent header. This is this page's pass mark.
- How to test
- Load the homepage on a phone, one-handed. You should reach call, email, or booking without opening a buried page.
Pass mark on this page, not a published standard.
4. Tap targets
- What to test
- Whether buttons, links, and form controls are large enough to hit with a finger.
- Pass mark
- Each pointer target is at least 24 by 24 CSS pixels (WCAG 2.2 SC 2.5.8).
- How to test
- On a phone, tap every primary control. If two controls sit next to each other, there should be enough space that you do not hit the wrong one.
Source: Understanding SC 2.5.8: Target Size (Minimum) (Level AA), read 20 November 2026.
5. Text contrast
- What to test
- Whether body text stays readable against its background.
- Pass mark
- Normal text has a contrast ratio of at least 4.5:1 (WCAG 2.2 SC 1.4.3).
- How to test
- Check the main body, captions, and placeholder text. Light grey on white is the usual fail.
Source: Understanding SC 1.4.3: Contrast (Minimum) (Level AA), read 20 November 2026.
6. Readable without zooming
- What to test
- Whether you can read the page on a phone without pinch-zooming to follow a sentence.
- Pass mark
- Text can be resized up to 200 percent without loss of content or functionality (WCAG 2.2 SC 1.4.4), and the viewport does not block zoom.
- How to test
- Open the page on a phone. Pinch-zoom must work. The website grader flags a viewport that sets user-scalable=no or maximum-scale at 1 or below.
Source: Understanding SC 1.4.4: Resize Text (Level AA), read 20 November 2026.
7. Proof next to the call to action
- What to test
- Whether reviews, work, or accreditations sit where the visitor is asked to act.
- Pass mark
- At least one piece of proof — a review, a piece of work, or an accreditation — is visible next to the primary call to action. This is this page's pass mark.
- How to test
- Scroll to the main button on home and on one service page. If proof only lives on a testimonials URL, this check fails.
Pass mark on this page, not a published standard.
8. Only the pages you need
- What to test
- Whether every live URL has a job.
- Pass mark
- Each indexed page has one job, and there are no empty, duplicate, or coming-soon URLs. This is this page's pass mark.
- How to test
- List the pages in the nav and the sitemap. Drop any URL that repeats another page or has no next step.
Pass mark on this page, not a published standard.
9. Short, labelled forms
- What to test
- Whether a form can be completed, and whether people who will not submit it can still reach you.
- Pass mark
- Every field has a visible label (WCAG 2.2 SC 3.3.2). The form is short. A tel: and a mailto: link exist on the same page so a visitor can call or email without submitting.
- How to test
- Open contact or booking. Read every label with the placeholder hidden. Confirm tel: and mailto: links work on a phone.
Source: Understanding SC 3.3.2: Labels or Instructions (Level A), read 20 November 2026.
10. Page titles and one H1
- What to test
- Whether each page names itself in the tab and in the heading.
- Pass mark
- Each page has a unique title element and exactly one H1. Google uses the title element among the sources for the title link; one H1 is this checklist's pass mark and the website grader's published search-basics check.
- How to test
- View source or run the website grader. Repeat on home, one service page, and contact.
Source: Influencing your title links in search results | Google Search Central, read 20 November 2026.
11. Domain, hosting, and logins in your name
- What to test
- Whether you can take the site with you if a vendor relationship ends.
- Pass mark
- The domain registrar account, the hosting account, and the CMS or editor login are in your organisation's name, not a contractor's personal email.
- How to test
- Open the registrar, the host, and the editor. The account holder should match the business. Read the glossary entries for domain name, website hosting, CMS, and website ownership if any of those words are unclear.
Pass mark on this page, not a published standard.
12. A named person who updates it
- What to test
- Whether someone can change a phone number or a price this week.
- Pass mark
- You can name the person who updates the site. 'The intern' or 'we'll see' fails. This is this page's pass mark.
- How to test
- Write the name down. If you cannot, this check fails even if the pages look finished.
Pass mark on this page, not a published standard.
What your score means
Add the passes. The bands below are this page's reading of a 0–12 count. They are not Google's Core Web Vitals bands and they are not a ranking claim.
| Score | What it means |
|---|---|
| 11–12 | The design is holding. Keep the named person updating it. Patch anything that still fails. |
| 8–10 | Patch the fails. A rebuild is not required yet if you can change the theme, the host, and the copy yourself. |
| 5–7 | Several pass marks fail. Fix the measurable ones first. If the theme or host is the blocker, it may be time to leave the platform rather than patch it. |
| 0–4 | Time to rebuild rather than patch. A new front on a builder you have outgrown is still a rebuild, not a settings change. |
A 0–12 count of this checklist. Not a Lighthouse score.
Rebuild rather than patch when the fails sit in a theme or host you cannot change. Start with 7 things Wix and WordPress won't let you fix if you are still deciding whether to leave, then switching from Wix or Squarespace for the move itself.
Cost of a patch versus a rebuild is on how much a website costs and the website cost calculator.
Run the website grader first for speed and mobile, then get in touch if you want the rest rebuilt. Pricing is $500/month, first month paid upfront, with full ownership after 24 months.
Nuvora builds custom websites you fully control, for $500/month, first month paid upfront, with full ownership after 24 months.